Find the Best Home Insurance Providers in New Carlisle, OH 45344

Searching for home insurance in New Carlisle, OH? This local directory is designed to help homeowners, renters, and landlords connect with nearby home insurance agents and companies offering competitive coverage options. Whether you’re a first-time homeowner, protecting a vacation home, or renewing your existing policy, this page connects you with a range of service providers in your area.


Home Insurance Options in New Carlisle, OH

Protecting your home in {City} starts with choosing the right insurance provider. Based on coverage options, affordability, and customer satisfaction, these top-rated home insurance companies offer trusted protection for homeowners in {City}.

Kevin Whitten Insurance Inc

105 South Main St # B, New Carlisle, OH
Finance and Insurance

Gorman Patti L

128 North Main St, New Carlisle, OH
Finance and Insurance

Trostel Chapman Dunbar Fraley

507 West Jefferson St, New Carlisle, OH
Other Services (except Public Administration)

Dayview Retirement Village

1885 North Dayton Lakeview Road, New Carlisle, OH
Health Care and Social Assistance

Fraley Preston

507 West Jefferson St, New Carlisle, OH
Other Services (except Public Administration)

Gammas Quilts

1732 Lundgren Road, New Carlisle, OH
Retail Trade

Honey Creek Village

11000 Marquart Road, New Carlisle, OH
Real Estate and Rental and Leasing

Fraley Larry

507 West Jefferson St, New Carlisle, OH
Other Services (except Public Administration)

Blevins Inc

1790 Dalton Drive, New Carlisle, OH
Wholesale Trade

Brian A Grimone-Nationwide

412 North Main St # 2, New Carlisle, OH
Finance and Insurance

Thrivent Financial For Lutherans

902 Brookfield Drive, New Carlisle, OH
Finance and Insurance

Imagine 320 Inc

11612 Knight Court, New Carlisle, OH
Health Care and Social Assistance

Hot Rods Classic Truck Parts

9625 Milton Carlisle Road, New Carlisle, OH
Other Services (except Public Administration)

First Insurance & Investments

309 North Main St, New Carlisle, OH
Finance and Insurance

Estep Jr Orbie

507 West Jefferson St, New Carlisle, OH
Other Services (except Public Administration)

Reisingers Home Improvement

1002 Brookfield Drive, New Carlisle, OH
Other Services (except Public Administration)

Brookwood Mobile Home Park

3435 Michelle Drive, New Carlisle, OH
Real Estate and Rental and Leasing

Milliken-Williams Insurance

128 North Main St, New Carlisle, OH
Finance and Insurance

Farmers Insurance

327 South Main St, New Carlisle, OH
Finance and Insurance

Doug Kilfoyle Insurance

325 South Main St, New Carlisle, OH
Finance and Insurance

Brown Renick

304 Galewood Drive, New Carlisle, OH
Finance and Insurance

The Mcglothin Insurance Agency

327 South Main St # A, New Carlisle, OH
Finance and Insurance

Drive Insurance From Progressive

128 North Main St, New Carlisle, OH
Finance and Insurance

Center Lark

19 John Avenue, New Carlisle, OH
Finance and Insurance

J & R Insurance

100 South Church St, New Carlisle, OH
Finance and Insurance
PreviousNext


Home Insurance Options in New Carlisle, OH

The providers listed in this directory offer a range of home insurance products, which may include:

  • Standard HO-3 policies (dwelling, liability, and personal property)

  • Condo insurance (HO-6)

  • Renters insurance (HO-4)

  • Landlord or rental property insurance

  • Flood and earthquake coverage (where applicable)

  • High-value home policies

  • Vacant home insurance

  • Umbrella liability protection


Types of Coverage You May Need in New Carlisle

Basic Homeowners Insurance (HO-3)

This standard policy protects the physical structure of your home, your belongings, and provides liability coverage in case someone is injured on your property.

Common searches:
“Home insurance quotes in New Carlisle”
“Best homeowners insurance companies near me”


Renters Insurance (HO-4)

If you're renting, renters insurance protects your personal property from fire, theft, or vandalism and may include liability coverage.

Related queries:
“Cheap renters insurance OH”
“Do landlords require renters insurance in New Carlisle?”


Condo Insurance (HO-6)

Covers the interior of your condo unit, personal property, and liability protection. Often used alongside the condo association’s master policy.

Searched as:
“Condo insurance in 45344”
“HO-6 insurance policy for condos”


Landlord Insurance

Provides coverage for rental properties, including the structure, liability protection, and loss of rental income.

Also searched:
“Rental property insurance New Carlisle”
“Landlord insurance policies near me”


Additional Coverage Options

  • Flood Insurance (especially if your property is in a FEMA-designated flood zone)

  • Earthquake Insurance (depending on region)

  • Scheduled personal property (for jewelry, collectibles, etc.)

  • Umbrella Liability Policies for broader protection


Popular Home Insurance Searches in New Carlisle, OH

This page is structured to align with common local user intent, such as:

  • “Compare home insurance quotes 45344”

  • “Best homeowners insurance for new homebuyers”

  • “Cheap home insurance in New Carlisle”

  • “Do I need flood insurance in OH?”

  • “Top-rated home insurance companies near me”


What Impacts Home Insurance Rates in New Carlisle?

Home insurance premiums can vary significantly based on:

  • Age, size, and rebuild cost of your home

  • Proximity to fire stations and hydrants

  • Local weather and natural disaster risks

  • Claims history (yours and the home’s)

  • Your credit score (in most states)

  • Bundled policies (home + auto = discount)

  • Deductible amount and coverage limits

Providers listed here may offer free quotes, local risk assessments, and assistance with selecting policy add-ons.


Why Use This Home Insurance Directory for New Carlisle?

  • Neutral Listings: No promotions or paid placement

  • Search Engine Optimized: Designed to match common queries and ranking signals

  • Local Focus: Specifically for New Carlisle, 45344, and surrounding areas

  • User Friendly: Contact providers directly—no account required


Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

What is the average cost of home insurance in New Carlisle?

Homeowners insurance costs vary by property size, location, and risk factors. Use this directory to compare providers and request accurate quotes for your specific situation.

Can I bundle my home and auto insurance in OH?

Yes, many providers offer discounts when you bundle multiple policies. It’s one of the most effective ways to lower your total premium.

Do I need flood insurance in New Carlisle?

It depends on your home’s location. Standard policies don’t cover flood damage. If your home is in a flood zone, you may need a separate NFIP-backed or private flood insurance policy.

Are there home insurance policies for rental properties?

Yes. Landlord or rental dwelling policies cover the structure, liability risks, and may include loss of rental income coverage.

How do I compare home insurance quotes?

Reach out to several local providers listed on this page. Be sure to ask about deductibles, exclusions, replacement value vs. actual cash value, and available discounts.


Start Comparing Home Insurance Providers in New Carlisle, OH

Whether you're buying a new home or renewing your coverage, use this directory to explore local and national home insurance providers. Many offer free estimates, customizable policy options, and discounts for bundled services. Protect your investment with the right coverage tailored to your needs.