Compare Car Insurance Providers in Shelby, OH 44875

Looking for affordable car insurance in Shelby, OH? This page features an organized local directory of independent agents, national carriers, and car insurance brokers that serve your area. Whether you're shopping for liability-only coverage, full coverage auto insurance, or high-risk SR-22 policies, this resource helps you explore local and national providers near you — all in one place.


Find Auto Insurance Services in Shelby

Searching for the best car insurance in {City}? These top-rated auto insurers offer competitive rates, excellent customer service, and reliable coverage options to keep you protected on the road.

Stoodt Insurance

100 West Main St # 3, Shelby, OH
Finance and Insurance

Trent Ins Group Inc-Nationwi

22 West Whitney Avenue, Shelby, OH
Finance and Insurance

Sutter's Home Decorating

72 West Main St, Shelby, OH
Retail Trade

Mansfield Avenue Car Wash

44 Mansfield Avenue, Shelby, OH
Other Services (except Public Administration)

America Insurance Inc

, Shelby, OH
Finance and Insurance

Shelby Mutual Ins Agency Inc

55 West Main St, Shelby, OH
Finance and Insurance

Thauvette Linda

4357 Weidner Road, Shelby, OH
Finance and Insurance

Behavioral Data Systems

2357 Horning Road, Shelby, OH
Health Care and Social Assistance

Brian Carson Insurance

206 Mansfield Avenue, Shelby, OH
Finance and Insurance

Wallace Auto Detailing

4120 Wareham Road, Shelby, OH
Retail Trade

Herbert Cole

115 South Gamble St, Shelby, OH
Retail Trade

Thrivent Financial For Lutherans

102 West Main St, Shelby, OH
Finance and Insurance

Jamie Bennett-Allstate Agent

25 North Gamble St, Shelby, OH
Finance and Insurance

Korbas Lisa

102 West Main St, Shelby, OH
Finance and Insurance

American Family Insurance

153 Mansfield Avenue, Shelby, OH
Finance and Insurance

Central Ohio Glass LLC

, Shelby, OH
Retail Trade

State Farm Insurance

206 Mansfield Avenue, Shelby, OH
Finance and Insurance

Cool Ridge Corp

2557 Myers Road, Shelby, OH
Other Services (except Public Administration)

Whippet Auto Sales

273 Mansfield Avenue, Shelby, OH
Retail Trade

Rbmog Inc

52 Mohican St # 1, Shelby, OH
Retail Trade

Berger's Family Auto Sales Inc

3754 State Route 39, Shelby, OH

Adams, Albert & Curry Agency, Inc

49 W Main Street, Shelby, OH

Detillion Enterprise Inc

64 Broadway St, Shelby, OH
Health Care and Social Assistance

On The Loose N Running 4 H Clu

3612 Plymuth Sprngmill Road, Shelby, OH
Finance and Insurance

W & W Development CO

6965 Baker County Road 47, Shelby, OH
Other Services (except Public Administration)
PreviousNext

Disclaimer: This directory is for informational use only. We do not verify, recommend, or endorse any insurance agent or company listed. Always perform independent research before selecting a provider.


Find Auto Insurance Services in Shelby

Explore a variety of auto insurance coverage options offered by local agents and companies in Shelby:

  • Liability-Only Insurance

  • Full Coverage Insurance

  • Collision & Comprehensive Coverage

  • Uninsured Motorist Coverage

  • SR-22 & High-Risk Auto Insurance

  • Teen & New Driver Insurance

  • Commercial Vehicle Insurance

  • Ride-Share Driver Insurance (Uber/Lyft)

  • Classic Car Insurance

  • Pay-Per-Mile and Usage-Based Policies


Top Search Queries Related to Car Insurance in Shelby, OH

This page is optimized to serve the most commonly searched terms, including:

  • “Cheap car insurance in Shelby”

  • “Best auto insurance rates near me”

  • “Compare car insurance quotes 44875”

  • “SR-22 insurance in OH”

  • “No down payment car insurance Shelby”

  • “Car insurance for teens and students”

  • “Affordable full coverage auto insurance OH”

By matching user intent, we help connect you with local resources and insurers that may offer personalized quotes based on your situation.


Common Car Insurance Coverages Explained

Liability-Only Insurance

Meets the minimum legal requirement in most states. Covers bodily injury and property damage caused to others when you’re at fault.

Popular Search Phrases:
“Minimum liability auto insurance Shelby”
“State required car insurance OH”


Full Coverage Car Insurance

Includes liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage. This is often required if you finance or lease your car.

Search Terms to Rank:
“Cheap full coverage insurance near me”
“Best car insurance with accident protection”


High-Risk & SR-22 Insurance

If you have a DUI, accident history, or lapse in coverage, some insurers in Shelby may file SR-22 forms or offer non-standard auto insurance.

Queries It Matches:
“SR-22 car insurance OH”
“Insurance after DUI in Shelby”


Insurance for Teens, Students, and New Drivers

Many providers offer discounts for good grades, safe driving, and defensive driving courses — especially useful for younger drivers.

Common Searches:
“Cheap car insurance for teens in Shelby”
“Auto insurance for student drivers”


Ride-Share & Delivery Driver Insurance

Drivers for apps like Uber, Lyft, DoorDash, or Instacart need hybrid commercial/personal policies or gap coverage.

Popular Terms:
“Uber driver car insurance Shelby”
“Delivery insurance policy options”


What Affects Car Insurance Rates in Shelby, OH?

Car insurance quotes vary widely depending on:

  • Your driving record

  • Vehicle type and value

  • ZIP code and crime rate

  • Age, gender, and marital status

  • Credit history (in most states)

  • Annual mileage

  • Past claims or gaps in coverage

Use this directory to compare offers and speak directly to providers who understand local market rates and laws in OH.


Why Use This Auto Insurance Directory in Shelby?

  • Neutral Listings: We don’t promote any specific insurer or broker.

  • Optimized for Local Search: Built around high-volume search terms in the car insurance niche.

  • Simple to Use: Browse, compare, and connect without needing to enter personal details.

  • Broad Coverage: Includes national brands and independent local agents.

Whether you need budget-friendly liability coverage or full coverage with roadside assistance, this page connects you to trusted sources serving the Shelby area.


Compare Car Insurance Quotes in Shelby, OH Today

Finding the right car insurance can help protect your finances, your vehicle, and your legal standing. Use the listings below to connect with licensed car insurance agents and companies in Shelby. Many offer free quotes, policy comparisons, and help finding discounts you might qualify for.