Top Rated Insurance Services in Buffalo, NY 14221

Looking for trusted insurance professionals in your area? Our directory connects you with a wide range of insurance companies, agents, and brokers in Buffalo, NY who may be able to assist you with your personal or commercial coverage needs. Whether you're interested in auto, home, life, health, or business insurance, you'll find multiple options listed here.

Disclaimer: This is an independent directory. We do not verify or endorse any company or individual listed on this page. Please perform your own research and consult directly with providers before making any decisions.


Best Insurance Providers in Buffalo

Looking for reliable insurance coverage in {City}? Here are the top-rated insurance companies based on customer reviews, financial strength, and service quality:

Progressive Casualty Ins CO

20 Lawrence Bell Drive # 200, Buffalo, NY
Finance and Insurance

Mes Management Service Inc

303 Cayuga Road # 150, Buffalo, NY
Finance and Insurance

Wissel John

Po Box 980, Buffalo, NY
Finance and Insurance

Mitchell Agency LLC

831 Maple Road # 1b, Buffalo, NY
Finance and Insurance

Martin B Breen Clu

37 Franklin St, Buffalo, NY
Finance and Insurance

State Farm Insurance

3676 South Park Avenue, Buffalo, NY
Finance and Insurance

Principal Life Insurance Company

5500 Main St # 304, Buffalo, NY
Finance and Insurance

Paul Revere Life Insurance CO

491 Potters Road, Buffalo, NY
Finance and Insurance

Trade Credit Insurance LLC

5373 Transit Road, Buffalo, NY
Finance and Insurance

Alaimo Jo

50 Fountain Plaza # 1100, Buffalo, NY
Finance and Insurance

Fitzgerald Eimiller Walsh Ltd

3388 Sheridan Drive, Buffalo, NY
Finance and Insurance

F J C Budget Plan Inc

1274 Bailey Avenue, Buffalo, NY
Finance and Insurance

Kenneth Sodaro

257 West Genesee St # 100, Buffalo, NY
Finance and Insurance

Gocella Tony

2875 Union Road # 7a, Buffalo, NY
Finance and Insurance

Mesi Agency Inc

5150 Main St, Buffalo, NY
Finance and Insurance

John Revelas Insurance

4457 Chestnut Ridge Road, Buffalo, NY
Finance and Insurance

Long & Katzman

475 International Drive, Buffalo, NY
Finance and Insurance

Blatchley Insurance

3022 Genesee St, Buffalo, NY
Finance and Insurance

Niagara Montauk Insurance

424 Main St Ste 1902, Buffalo, NY

Gigante Agency Inc

86 Ivyhurst Road, Buffalo, NY
Finance and Insurance

Consolidate Insurance Agent

36 Hopkins Road, Buffalo, NY
Finance and Insurance

State Farm Insurance

1021 Union Road, Buffalo, NY
Finance and Insurance

Aflac

2829 Wehrle Drive, Buffalo, NY
Finance and Insurance

Merchants Mutual Insurance CO

250 Main St, Buffalo, NY
Finance and Insurance

P & C Solutions LLC

4246 Ridge Lea Road, Buffalo, NY
Finance and Insurance


Compare Local Insurance Providers in Buffalo

Choosing the right insurance provider can be confusing, especially with so many options and policy types. That’s why we’ve compiled this detailed list of licensed insurance agents, brokers, and companies serving Buffalo and the surrounding areas.

This directory includes professionals who may specialize in:

  • Auto insurance

  • Homeowners and renters insurance

  • Health insurance

  • Life insurance

  • Disability and long-term care insurance

  • Business and commercial insurance

  • Specialty coverage (such as pet insurance, travel insurance, and cyber insurance)

Each provider operates independently and offers varying levels of service, rates, and coverage options. Be sure to reach out to multiple companies to compare quotes and understand your options.


Popular Insurance Types in Buffalo, NY

Auto Insurance in Buffalo

One of the most commonly searched insurance needs is car coverage. People search for:

  • "Cheap car insurance near me"

  • "Compare car insurance rates Buffalo"

  • "Best auto insurance companies in NY"

  • "Car insurance quotes without credit check"

Auto insurance helps cover financial losses from accidents, theft, or damage to your vehicle. Depending on the state, minimum liability coverage is typically required. Many drivers choose full coverage policies that include comprehensive and collision protection.

Local agents often offer:

  • Minimum liability coverage (required by law)

  • Comprehensive and collision insurance

  • Uninsured/underinsured motorist protection

  • SR-22 filings

  • Discounts for bundling, safe driving, and low mileage

Homeowners and Renters Insurance

These are essential for protecting your residence and belongings. Users frequently search:

  • "Affordable home insurance in Buffalo"

  • "Does renters insurance cover theft?"

  • "Compare homeowners insurance quotes"

Whether you own a home or rent an apartment, protecting your property is crucial. Homeowners insurance covers damages caused by fire, weather events, theft, and more. Renters insurance protects your personal items in a leased space and often includes liability protection as well.

Insurance brokers listed may provide:

  • Replacement cost or actual cash value coverage

  • Liability and guest injury protection

  • Protection for jewelry, electronics, and valuables

  • Flood or earthquake add-ons (may be separate policies)

Health Insurance Plans in Buffalo

Health insurance is a major concern for individuals, families, and small businesses. Top search queries include:

  • "Best health insurance plans in Buffalo"

  • "Short-term health insurance near me"

  • "Affordable ACA health plans NY"

  • "Health insurance for freelancers or self-employed"

Health coverage helps with the cost of doctor visits, hospital stays, medications, and preventive care. Plans vary widely by provider, so comparing benefits and network access is essential.

Providers may offer:

  • Marketplace and Affordable Care Act (ACA) plans

  • PPO, HMO, and EPO networks

  • Family and individual coverage

  • Employer-sponsored group plans

  • Temporary or catastrophic coverage

Life Insurance

Planning for the future is one of the most important financial steps. Searchers often look for:

  • "Compare term life insurance quotes"

  • "Best life insurance companies in Buffalo"

  • "Whole vs term life insurance"

Life insurance provides peace of mind for your family, covering funeral expenses, debts, or lost income after a death. Policy types vary by length, cash value, and premium costs.

Agents may assist with:

  • Term life policies (10, 20, or 30 years)

  • Whole life and universal life plans

  • Final expense or burial insurance

  • No-medical-exam options

Business and Commercial Insurance

For entrepreneurs and established businesses alike, proper coverage is essential. Popular search intents include:

  • "Small business insurance Buffalo"

  • "General liability insurance for contractors"

  • "Business interruption coverage quotes"

Commercial insurance protects your company from financial risk due to lawsuits, property damage, employee injury, and more.

Offerings can include:

  • General liability insurance

  • Workers' compensation coverage

  • Commercial auto insurance

  • Cyber liability insurance

  • Professional liability or errors and omissions (E&O) insurance

  • Business owner’s policies (BOP)


Related Insurance Needs in Buffalo, NY

In addition to the core policy types, many people search for:

  • Pet Insurance – For unexpected vet bills and surgeries

  • Travel Insurance – Coverage for trip cancellation, medical emergencies, or lost baggage

  • Boat and RV Insurance

  • Mobile Home Insurance

  • Event Insurance – For weddings, parties, and corporate events

These are often provided by full-service brokers or specialty agencies.


Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

How can I get the best insurance rates in Buffalo?
Contact multiple providers listed here to compare rates and plans. Be sure to ask about bundling discounts and policy-specific incentives.

Is insurance mandatory in NY?
Some forms of insurance are required by law. For example, auto liability insurance is legally required in most states. Homeowners insurance may be required by mortgage lenders, and certain types of business insurance are mandatory for compliance.

Can I purchase insurance online or do I need to visit an agent?
Most providers allow online applications, especially for auto and renters insurance. However, consulting with an agent can help you understand policy details and avoid coverage gaps.

Do these listings represent verified insurance agents?
No. This directory does not verify, endorse, or recommend any specific provider. All information is for general reference only. You are encouraged to research reviews, credentials, and licensing before working with any agency or agent.


Why Use This Directory for Insurance in Buffalo?

  • You can browse dozens of insurance providers and compare offerings without pressure.

  • There’s no cost to use this directory.

  • Providers are organized by location and category to make your search easier.

  • The listings may include a variety of national carriers and independent brokers.

Most importantly, this directory does not profit from your decisions. We do not sell insurance. We do not verify credentials. We simply gather and organize publicly available information to help you begin your research.


Begin Comparing Insurance Services in Buffalo, NY

Choosing insurance is a critical financial decision. Use this page as a starting point to find local insurance agents, brokers, and companies that fit your needs. Request multiple quotes, ask the right questions, and make a choice that provides the coverage and peace of mind you’re looking for.

Whether you're shopping for the first time, renewing a policy, or switching carriers, having access to multiple providers in one place gives you the upper hand.

Check out Best Insurance Services in other cities