Compare Auto Insurance Providers in New Windsor, NY 12553

If you're searching for auto insurance in New Windsor, NY, you've come to the right place. This local directory helps residents and drivers in the area find nearby providers offering a wide range of car insurance options — from basic liability coverage to full coverage policies and SR-22 high-risk filings.

This guide lists both local agents and national insurance carriers who provide car insurance services in 12553 and the surrounding areas.


Best Auto Insurance Services in New Windsor

Finding affordable and dependable car insurance in {City} is easier with the right provider. Based on customer satisfaction, claims handling, and coverage options, these are the best auto insurance companies serving drivers in {City}.

Oconnor John J

316 Blooming Grove Turnpike, New Windsor, NY
Finance and Insurance

State Farm Bus Opportunities

100 Commerce Drive # 101, New Windsor, NY
Finance and Insurance

Ernst Richard

460 Temple Hill Road, New Windsor, NY
Finance and Insurance

Farm Family Life Insurance CO

88 Old Route 9w, New Windsor, NY
Finance and Insurance

Marshall & Sterling Insurance

103 Executive Dr
Suite 300, New Windsor, NY

Marjorie Ciucci, New York Life

, New Windsor, NY

Priority Recovery Inc

34 Walnut St, New Windsor, NY
Administrative and Support and Waste Management and Remediation Services

Allstate

620 Little Britain Road, New Windsor, NY
Finance and Insurance

Enterprise Rent-A-Car

2375 State Route 32, New Windsor, NY
Real Estate and Rental and Leasing

Lightning Lube Inc

400 Blooming Grove Turnpike, New Windsor, NY
Other Services (except Public Administration)

Big Z Life & Health Brokerage

Browns Drive, New Windsor, NY
Finance and Insurance

BARRYS AUTOMOTIVE Inc.

274 windsor Highway, New Windsor, NY

Performance Motor Sports

2899 Us Route 9w, New Windsor, NY
Other Services (except Public Administration)

Roger Dwyer-Allstate Agent

357 Windsor Highway # 500, New Windsor, NY
Finance and Insurance

Bryan Insurance Agency, LLC

3068 Rte 9w, New Windsor, NY

Cooney Steve

3068 Us Route 9w # 200, New Windsor, NY
Finance and Insurance

George Thompson Insurance

357 Old Forge Hill Road # 800, New Windsor, NY
Finance and Insurance

Frank Jannotti Insurance Agncy

20 Browns Drive, New Windsor, NY
Finance and Insurance

Bryan Insurance

3068 Us Route 9w # 500, New Windsor, NY

Metropolitan Investigation

1010 D St, New Windsor, NY
Finance and Insurance

Overdose Motorsports

174 Vails Gate Heights Drive, New Windsor, NY
Retail Trade

No Name Insurance

161 Windsor Highway # 200, New Windsor, NY
Finance and Insurance

Advance Auto Parts

115 Temple Hill Road, New Windsor, NY
Retail Trade

New York Life

460 Temple Hill Road, New Windsor, NY
Finance and Insurance

The Hertz Corporation

1032 1st St # 112, New Windsor, NY
Real Estate and Rental and Leasing


Find Car Insurance Services in New Windsor

Auto insurance providers in New Windsor may offer:

  • State minimum liability-only policies

  • Full coverage auto insurance (collision + comprehensive)

  • High-risk or SR-22 coverage

  • Insurance for teen and student drivers

  • Pay-per-mile and usage-based policies

  • Uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage

  • Auto insurance for rideshare or delivery drivers

  • Commercial fleet insurance

  • Multi-car or bundle policy discounts


Understanding Auto Insurance Options

Liability-Only Car Insurance

This type of insurance meets state minimum requirements and typically covers bodily injury and property damage to others when you're at fault.

Often searched as:
“Minimum coverage auto insurance in New Windsor”
“Cheap liability car insurance NY”


Full Coverage Auto Insurance

Full coverage includes liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage. It’s ideal for leased or financed vehicles and offers protection against theft, vandalism, and natural disasters.

Related searches:
“Full coverage auto insurance near me”
“Cheap full coverage insurance in 12553”


SR-22 and High-Risk Insurance

If you're a high-risk driver due to a DUI, suspended license, or lapse in coverage, you may need an insurer that offers SR-22 insurance filing.

Common user queries:
“SR-22 insurance providers in New Windsor”
“Car insurance after DUI in NY”


Teen, Student & New Driver Insurance

Many insurance companies offer policies for first-time drivers, with potential discounts for students with good grades or completion of driver’s education courses.

Popular terms:
“Teen driver car insurance New Windsor”
“Best auto insurance for students near me”


Insurance for Rideshare & Delivery Drivers

If you drive for Uber, Lyft, DoorDash, or Instacart, you may need special coverage that bridges the gap between personal and commercial auto insurance.

Matched searches:
“Uber driver car insurance New Windsor”
“Delivery insurance coverage in NY”


Factors That Affect Auto Insurance Rates in New Windsor

Rates for car insurance can vary widely, even within the same ZIP code. Key influencing factors include:

  • Driving history (accidents, tickets, DUIs)

  • Credit score (where applicable)

  • Age, gender, marital status

  • Vehicle type, usage, and mileage

  • Local accident and theft statistics

  • Prior insurance claims or coverage gaps

Using this directory helps you compare multiple providers to find the best combination of cost and coverage.


Why Use This Auto Insurance Directory for New Windsor, NY?

  • Neutral & Unbiased Listings: We do not endorse any company listed here.

  • Search-Optimized Layout: Built to match real search intent from Google users.

  • Local Coverage: Tailored for residents in New Windsor, NY and nearby ZIP codes.

  • User Friendly: Browse options without login, sign-up, or sharing personal details.


Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

What is the cheapest auto insurance in New Windsor?

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer, as prices vary based on your record, vehicle, and other factors. Use this directory to compare quotes from multiple providers to find the best rate.

Can I get auto insurance with no down payment in New Windsor, NY?

Some companies offer no-down-payment car insurance, although it often depends on credit, driving history, and insurer policy.

Who offers the best SR-22 insurance in NY?

Several insurers offer SR-22 filings, especially those that specialize in non-standard or high-risk auto insurance. Always confirm directly with the provider.

How do I get car insurance quotes in New Windsor?

Use this directory to locate nearby providers and request free quotes. Many offer online, phone, or in-person assistance.

What if I need auto insurance for multiple cars?

Many insurers offer multi-vehicle discounts. Look for local agents who can help bundle policies for better rates.


Start Comparing Auto Insurance in New Windsor, NY

Whether you're seeking budget-friendly liability insurance or comprehensive coverage for your new car, the local providers listed here can help. Request free quotes, ask about available discounts, and find a plan that fits your driving needs and budget.